Basis Lab

Waves, Modes and Frequency

The Ring That Forgets

Last timePushing at the Right Moment

Heat spreading round a ring uses the same shapes as a vibrating string, but they decay instead of oscillating, and the fine detail decays first. What survives is a single number.

A ring of metal is heated at one spot and left alone. Everybody knows what happens

next. What is worth noticing is how little has to change in the machinery of the last

six lessons to say exactly what happens next, and in what order.

FIG 1The rule for spreading
how hot the ring is at the jth point around it. The points are joined in a loop, so the last is a neighbour of the first
how fast that temperature is changing. One dot, not two: this is a speed of change, not an acceleration of change
twice the amount by which the average of the two neighbours exceeds this point. Positive when both neighbours are hotter, so the point warms
how readily heat moves between neighbours. It sets the overall pace and nothing else: it cannot change which shapes decay first
Compare this with the rule for a chain of beads in the third lesson. The right-hand side is identical: a point compared with the average of its two neighbours. The whole difference is on the left. For the beads that quantity drove an acceleration, and the result was oscillation. Here it drives a velocity, and the result is decay. One dot instead of two is the entire distinction between a bell and a cooling ring.

Watching one ring forget

Four points round a loop, all the heat starting in one of them. The quantity held

fixed is the total, and the rule conserves it exactly, because whatever leaves one

point arrives at a neighbour.

FIG 2All the heat in one spot, spreading round a loop of four
00.20.40.60.81050100150200steps taken

the quantity that holdsunder 0.001% of it gone by the end, at every setting of every slider

1

240 of 240 steps

where the heat startedone step roundthe far sideone step round the other way
stepped by
x1 → x1 + D*(x2 + x4 - 2*x1) x2 → x2 + D*(x3 + x1 - 2*x2) x3 → x3 + D*(x4 + x2 - 2*x3) x4 → x4 + D*(x1 + x3 - 2*x4)
each rule reads
the state as it was when the step began
started at
x1 = 1.0, x2 = 0.0, x3 = 0.0, x4 = 0.0
held steady
the quantity that holds = x1 + x2 + x3 + x4
drift
under 0.001% over the run, against 0.20% allowed
The total is held fixed to within rounding, which is the only thing this system conserves. Watch the order of events rather than the end state. The two neighbours rise together and immediately, while the far side lags: it can only be reached through them. Then all three converge on a quarter each, and from there nothing further happens, for ever. The two neighbours stay equal throughout, because nothing in the ring distinguishes clockwise from anticlockwise. The slider is the only thing about the material that enters, and the point of being able to move it is to see what it cannot do: it stretches or squeezes the whole story along the horizontal and changes the order of nothing.

Two symmetries are visible there and both are forced rather than arranged. The two

neighbours behave identically because the starting state and the rule are both

unchanged by reflecting the ring. The end state is a flat quarter each because the

total is conserved and the flat shape is the only one the rule leaves alone.

The lesson stops here

3 more paragraphs to go

You have read the opening. The rest of the argument, the problems that check whether it landed, and the lines worth keeping at the end all come with a plan.

The first lesson of every course in the library reads the whole way through, free, so you can see exactly what the rest of them are.

See the planThe contents

This is the reading half

Starting the course gives you your own copy of it. Every idea on every page has problems standing under it, marked with a reason rather than a tick, and any sentence you do not believe can be opened and argued with. None of that can happen on a page nobody owns.

The contents

The rest of this course

  1. 01The One Rhythm Nearly Everything Falls Into
  2. 02Two Joined Pendulums and the Two Rhythms Hiding in Themopening only
  3. 03What a Clamped String Is Allowed to Doopening only
  4. 04Every Starting Shape Is a Sum of the Allowed Onesopening only
  5. 05A Travelling Wave Is Two Standing Onesopening only
  6. 06Pushing at the Rate a Thing Already Hasopening only
  7. 07The Ring That Forgetsyou are here
  8. 08Charges, Loops and a Wave With Nothing to Waveopening only

Read alongside